Nature Photographers Network
This is the preserved archive of the original Nature Photographers Network. The community continues at naturephotographers.network.
No Salmon...No Bears, No Trees?
‹ PreviousMan & Fauna GalleryNext ›

No Salmon...No Bears, No Trees?

by Brad Hill

Gallery: Man & FaunaPosted November 10, 2008657 views8 comments
Sorry about the long commentary...but this is an issue I feel passionate about...

Gruesome image? Yes. But the circumstances leading to the death of this black bear are even more chilling than this image. Read on...

The black bear who formerly lived within this skull inhabited an area of the northern coast of British Columbia, Canada that is known as the "Great Bear Rainforest. It was killed and eaten by a brown (or grizzly) bear in October of 2008. Normally grizzlies in the Great Bear Rainforest feed largely on spawning salmon in October. But in the autumn of 2008 an event with potentially catastrophic consequences occurred in a large number of drainages in the Great Bear Rainforest - virtually no salmon returned to spawn. The immediate result? A LOT of hungry grizzly (and black) bears were forced to turn to alternate food sources during a time when they are desperately trying to build up the nutritional stores needed to sustain them through their winter hibernation. We observed bears that are normally gorging themselves on salmon digging for relatively low-nutrition roots and bulbs, and, on two instances (in 8 days) we observed the outcome of grizzlies attacking and killing black bears. And, we saw a lot of bears that were much thinner than they should have been in October. While there'll be no scientific study done to verify this, it's likely that over-winter mortality of bears will be higher than normal this year and that many cubs will go un-born (i.e., the bear's reproductive rate will drop).

The long-term result? The temperate rainforest and ecosystem that makes up the Great Bear Rainforest is adapted to the (normally) huge annual inputs of nutrients and energy provided by the (normally) almost countless millions of salmon that spawn and then die (and are eaten or decompose) in the rivers of the region. Studies have shown that even the massive trees found in the Great Bear Rainforest contain isotopes of nitrogen which ultimately came from the carcasses of salmon (bears and wolves - especially subordinate ones - regularly drag salmon carcasses away from the rivers and off into the forest to eat in peace and, of course, leave the scraps to decompose). Remove the massive annual input of nutrients/energy from the equation and EVERY aspect of the ecosystem is affected. How dramatically will the ecosystem change and what form will the ecosystem change to? No one knows for sure...and I for one hope to hell we never find out!

So why almost no salmon in so many rivers in the fall of 2008? No one knows for sure yet, but every suggested cause (over-fishing; diseases and parasites introduced by fish farms; damage to the spawing streams through increased particulates associated with logging; warmer than normal ocean currents in the ocean off the west coast of Canada; etc.) is linked to human intervention/disturbance to the environment. Perhaps it's time for a complete moratorium on sport and commercial fishing of salmon on the Pacific coast until we have a better handle on what's going on. Too much is at stake to ignore the issue...

If anyone is interested, all the contextual information surrounding this shot (field notes, all camera settings and processing details, conservation, etc.), can be found here:

http://www.naturalart.ca/galleries/latest/detail_5.html.

Thanks for looking, and thanks in advance for any feedback on this image or issue.

Cheers...

Brad

Comments

8 comments
Comment posted by Guy Tal on November 11, 2008 at 9:25 PM
Very powerful image and great narrative.

Guy
Registered on November 1, 2003, 566 Posts, 15507 Comments
Comment posted by Steve Foss on November 14, 2008 at 12:22 PM
Brad, that's quite an emotional image that delivers a tortuous message all by itself because of the gaping jaws, the flesh left on the bones and the impression that the bear is fighting to avoid being pulled into the earth. The back story definitely is required to put the image's impact in perspective. Image and story make a solid team here.
Registered on June 7, 2006, 90 Posts, 525 Comments
Comment posted by Stan Rose on November 14, 2008 at 8:40 PM
Excellent shot, and a very important message. Deserves front page status, IMO.
Registered on September 15, 2005, 836 Posts, 17099 Comments
Comment posted by Richard Wong on November 22, 2008 at 11:08 PM
Gripping story and image combination. EPJ at it's finest.
Registered on February 2, 2006, 79 Posts, 2629 Comments
Comment posted by Kirk Greene on November 25, 2008 at 9:06 PM
Very powerful image that sheds light on a very concerning situation. Thanks for taking the time to provide the story behind the image.
Registered on May 12, 2004, 191 Posts, 1578 Comments
Comment posted by Sanford Dickerson on December 12, 2008 at 1:55 PM
Excellent image and first rate report. Unfortuneately, its like "whistling in the wind." The powers that be, will ignore this because, they have sold their souls to the "Corporate" bigwigs. Call me cynical, but thats the way I see it. And, sadly, it's happening all around the "world" :mad:
Registered on December 29, 2005, 19 Posts, 75 Comments
Comment posted by Pam Colander on January 23, 2009 at 12:30 AM
Powerful image and back story. I was watching a TV show about polar bears and grizzleys a couple of days ago. Seems with the shrinking sea ice and frozen tundra in the polar bears habitat, the grizzleys are expanding their territories northward. Encounters between these two are increasing with grizzleys having the advantage. Some resulting in death to the weakened polar bears and some interbreeding between the two. Yet another strike against polar bears survival.
Registered on December 7, 2006, 210 Posts, 1062 Comments
Comment posted by Cliff Forrest on May 17, 2009 at 11:06 PM
Hi Brad,
I totally agree with a fishing moratorium. Issues with first nation rights and fishing guide rights and jobs are irrelevant. The "I Want Mine" philosophy will leave a terrible legacy of life challenged oceans. Besides, they're what got us to this point. I thought we were known for learning from our mistakes. Those few people related issues are microscopic when placed beside the big picture. If a moratorium helps salmon populations and allows even one bear to survive that might not have, it's worth it. In spades. I'm drifting off the salmon subject a weeny bit, but the arrogance of people assuming their life is worth more to them than the life of a bears is to it is an ugly personality trait. Whether it's blowing a bird out of the sky in mid-flight or dropping a grizzly with a high powered rifle from a coward's distance they both should light everyone's fuse. And political people using just skin deep logic play Higher Power and pick which animals are expendable in the name of money and votes. The grizzly is a much more admirable creature than the one holding the rifle. Smarter, higher ethics and better lookin'.

With just about a years wait 'til the Khutz, Cheers,
-Cliff



Registered on March 3, 2009, 51 Posts, 78 Comments