Ice sculpture

I like this Dave, it's a good subject for B/W
Bob

Very well composed and nice shutter speed. For winter images I usually prefer a blueish toning.

This is FANTIASTICO!!!! I may suggest cloning out the two little branches on the very left of the image. Kudos!!! Oh, send me a print. Joe.

This is very nice Dave - works well in B&W too.

This is a lovely image. I agree with Andreas, a cooler tone would suit the subject matter.

Cheers,
Mark

Great choice on B&W! This is beautiful. I would agree with Joe about the left branch, but minor stuff. Very nice work.

Excellent bw work Dave!

That makes me shiver. Nice tonal values and texture in the water. Great b&w.

Unique comp and very nicely presented in B&W. There's a sense for me that the ice is sort of hovering over the scene and relatively distant from the water. I know this is an illusion (isn't it) that makes me stare a little harder at the image.

Very nicely done. The play between the intricate still ice forms and the perfectly captured water movement really holds my interest.

The sense of 2 layers, one over the other, created by the long exposure of the water, is disturbing and confusing. I feel you need something to somehow unite these 2 planes. In the same manner that a good landscape has a transition between fg and bg.

Excellent conversion and toning. Your comp works really well.

I like the flow and ice forms Dave. B&W sepia is wonderful as well. Nice work.

This is beautiful. I think you could push the whites a little bit though, and I, personally, would also prefer a cooler tone.

Beautiful, well composed image. Your b/w processing works really well. Like Doug suggested, I might consider pushing the whites a bit to provide a tad more luminosity to the image. Always love how ice can appear to be hovering over a stream like this. Excellent work.

Dave,

That is some amazing luminousity in the ice. I don't know where that light is coming from , but it definitely gets my attention and holds it. It looks almost 3D.

what a spot! nice b&w image. great contrast you got here. I think the whites would look better if they were pumped up a bit, just a thought. great comp.

Hi Dave Like the flow of the image,. the lighting is great. Very cool
Albert darmo canada