Nothin' But Fall Colors

OK, here's most of the shoreline, that includes yesterday's post as well as today's, and then some. I don't know if anyone would be interested in hanging such an extreme panorama (would probably have to be in segments), but I recorded it all.

I didn't see yesterday's post until just now. I like them both but of the two I prefer this one, not because of the rock, but the other one looks a little like it was taken at an oblique angle and I prefer this "straight on" version best. The color is sublime - looks like you're having a great year up there - I hope you send a little of it southward.

Yep, I still prefer the rock-pic, but I really like this one too!

The rock remains my choice.

Thanks guys.
That's an interesting observation, Bill. Both images are crops of the long pano in my comment. I didn't notice it before, but now it's obvious that the center of the pano is looking at the shore at pretty much a 90 degree angle, while the edges were trailing off into the distance as I rotated the camera from side to side. I suppose to get it all perfectly flat, I would have to do multiple tripod sets at the same elevation and distance, for hundreds of yards along the shore. That would be quite a challenge, since the shore was not straight, and it was covered with rocks, fallen trees, alders, cranberries, etc. Hmmm... Maybe it I shot it from my canoe...???

Hey! I just thought of how to do this! Line up 8 photographers in 8 canoes, equidistant from the shore, all with the same camera and lens, and have everyone line up their shots precisely with accurate compasses, and shoot simultaneously. The obvious answer a uniform superpanorama is aerial photography or satellites, but they could not get this low. Anyone want to bring your boats up here next October? Warning: It's a steep, boulder-hopping 0.6 mile climb to get to this pond, so bring a helper.

Wayne - I don't know what program you used to construct the pano, but PS has different "methods" of construction that should handle the situation for you. Plus, it's really not that noticeable - I think I was just being a nit.

Thanks Bill. I tried the "perspective" stitching method, but it exaggerated the edges too much. Besides, lining up 8 photographers in canoes sounds like a lot more fun.

Hey, why would we post photos if we were not asking for nit-picking?

I prefer the rock version as well Wayne, as it gives the scene a sense of depth. But, as far as which version would sell better, a graphic 50/50 reflection shot usually takes the cake. They're both marvelous shots. And for sheer impact, the pano is fabulous!

I suppose the rock provides some foreground interest, but for me the symmetry of this one can't be beat.

Always lovely scenes. Looks like you could get more darks out of this oen. NIce find!

aF

I have a canoe!! and a 5D3 with a 24-105. Now I just have to find a helper. Both images are really nice, Wayne, and I'm a little undecided which one I like best. Leaning towards the rock...I think.

Nick Bristol
Lone Rock, WI

Both are beautifully done and you couldn't go wrong with either version, but I prefer the prior post with the rock as it adds another element to an already fantastic scene. Gorgeous image, Wayne.

Ed

Well, I like them both but am leaning towards the first one with the rock. I know the 8 guys in 8 canoes was sort of a joke but if you really want to go hi-tech and show how with it you are, you need to get your own drone to mount a camera on and let it do the walkin' for you.

Tough call. I think I like the rock version slightly more but both are fine images.

The symmetry draws me in Wayne. The color and light are beautiful. I prefer your original in this post. I am typically not found of extreme panoramic images.

I'm not going to choose one over the other, there both beautiful scenes, and they both appeal to me in a slightly different way, love them both. I've seen this area photographed many times, without a doubt, I've never seen it photographed better. Your passion for photography really shows in your work. Gorgeous Wayne, in every way. Take care.
John

Very nice , Wayne. I like the perfect reflection a lot.
The full pano is great!

D&L

Wayne, I prefer the version of the picture without the rock. To me, the greatest interest in the photo is the contrast of the white tree trunks (real and reflected) with the multi-colored foliage. It draws me in and makes me want to look around.

Stunning reflection, Wayne. The almost pure whites of the tree trunks and those glowing colors make this quite an incredible autumn image. The image with the rock is gorgeous as well, but I think that the simplicity of this image really makes it sing a bit more. Fantastic.

This is just wonderful Wayne, but I still prefer the rocked version. I really like the way it anchors the photo; it's a nice point of contrast the amazing color around it.

I really enjoy the rock version and this version. They are gorgeous representations of the true nature of Autumn, and all the wonderful beauty she has to offer. Excellent work!!!!