Touch of Frost Too

Scott,
Hard to chose as these are all gorgeous but this maybe my favorite . The color palate is just beautiful. High contrast and warmer rendering works well.

There has been a glut of frosty leaves but this is one of the very nicest of them all with marvellous internal luminosity.

Of your 2 leafscapes, this is the most lively due to the frost luminosity.  I looked at the two images side by side and I feel this is far superior.  Good job.  My leaves are all brown and wet now.

This is wonderful. Well seen and presented. There is a delicacy to the scene of these objects that are soon to decay.

Another beauty Scott!  Such a beautiful combination of color, details, shapes - and the frost just ties everything together.

I like both images very much.  I like this one over the first in terms of the overall lighting and exposure. ie. the previous version I commented on some of the pale green leaves being a bit bright.  But for me, I might prefer the previous image when it comes to composition - ok, maybe composition isn't the right term, but I really liked the more compact, tighter comp from earlier. This one here is slightly wider, I think.  Minor points to be sure.

I think I would be pretty excited to have this in front of my camera!  Well done.

Lon

Scott, the choice is easy for me.  The extra contrast in this view adds a fine pop overall.  I also like having more leaves and texture included in the view.  Gives more places for my eyes to wander.  Setting up a shot like this is very hard and your comp. is terrific in how it creates a central rectangle with lots of interesting parts surrounded by complementary material.

Hi  Scott    I  think this type of  scene  lends itself better to  more graphic  detail .  this  is why  i like this one  a wee bit better.. also  the composition is more  interesting with the added leaves and the frost luminosity..

Albert Darmo
Canada

I prefer this one also, scott, such a lovely, balanced composition of color and shape. Minor nit but I might be tempted to experiment with a bit more sharpening, perhaps selectively, on the image without getting to over-sharpened.

This is wonderful, Scott. I really like the palette and the frosty edges and textures.  Comparing it to #1, it's a draw. The composition in #1 feels more thoughtful (but randomness is good in the second), and I like the warm colors of the second, especially the needles (but #1 colors feel more natural to me).  Like I said, it's a draw for me. Now I'll read what others wrote

What's not to like?  Beautiful in all aspects, color, light, arrangement, and the frost brings it all together.

These little scenes are just so beautiful. The previous version has a crayons feeling due to subtle contrast. This version is more vivid. Both are very nice in their own way. I am not going to choose.