Moon over Mayflowe Gulch B&W

this is my fourth time to Mayflower Gulch and I still haven't had much luck with photos from the area. but I Do like this Black and White with the quarter moon in it though

Posting here to see what you guys think

I decided to add this one for a good honest critique.

The clouds thenselves had this golden/yellow glow from the low sun

Of the 2 images I prefer your B&W one, the diagonals in it work well, and the moon is a nice addition. Two nits though, I would clone the airplane contrail, and I wish the boot trodden path wasn't in the composition; both these isues could be fixed perhaps in PS ;).

Hey Paul, it's looking like a nice clean image now, nice job with the cloning

Yup, nice job on the cloning. Now you need to work on contrast. The image is way too flat. Bumping up the blacks and a nice steep curve would make this pop. There lots of drama here waiting to come out.

here is my third rendition

phew