Punchbowl, no log is good log...

Couldn't resist, had to see for myself. (Though I did believe Jesse)

Yup, it's GONE!

I edited this on my laptop, so I'm wondering how it comes across on everyone else's monitors. Is it very flat?

Thanks,
Edward

Very nice. I might tone the sky down some - it's a bit distracting.

It looks rather purple to me, but my spider calibration popped up today and told me to recalibrate. So really i guess i shouldnt say anything.

Same for me -- it looks magenta-ish, but I'm overdue for calibration.

Nice comp; I like the stretch of cobbles. The little clouds are blown and the sky is pretty bright.

I like the composition but the sky and some of the colors look a bit off on my monitor.

I like this Edward, have never been to punchbowl but can see how popular it must be with photographers. I love the cobblestone streambed and view upstream to the falls. Some of the brighter mosses seem a bit too bright, but then I may be wrong not being there and I have seen mosses more yellow then green. Very nice capture!

Crop the sky maybe? Ditto what everyone else said. :)

I would like to see the falls a little more prominent. It's such a beautiful falls I just feel more of it should take up the frame. Maybe some waders or wait until the water gets warmer. Then of course, you have to shoot around all the people. Nice to see the log gone. Overall, not bad.

I like the perspective, but the sky is really blown and distracting. I do see a bit of a purple/magenta tint in the image. It almost looks like it was processed with an Orton effect or with HDR software with the way the walls of the gorge look. I really like how the bed of the stream shows. I'm definitely going to have to get out there soon.

Are waders needed to get to the falls? I've never been in that particular part of the gorge and am dying to get there this spring.

First off, I really like this perspective. I think the lighting shows off the moss-covered rock faces, and the FG rocks very well. It's a nice change I think. The color is definitely very magenta, and as some have said, the sky (and the FG rocks to some length) are a bit distracting and appear HDR-ish. There also seems to be a little bit of distortion overall. Fixing the magenta in the rocks and toning down the sky would go a long way I think.

Fixing the magenta and toning down the sky for sure.

You don't need waders to get this shot, but you do if you want to get up by the falls. (You may need a boat, I just don't know. The stream right by this photo is shallow enough.)

I have other compositions which feature the falls more prominently which I need to work on.

The sky is the big problem. It's about a 10 stop difference... very challenging.

Thanks for all the input, I really appreciate it! I'll repost when/if I get this dialed in any better.