Debjit,
I really like the composition, and the processing creates a nice mood. A couple of minor suggestions, though. The highlights in the cascade look a tad bright, especially considering the late hour. Secondly, there is some noticeable darkening on the upper right that could easily be evened out with a curves adjustment. Great job overall.
-Anish
Posted by Debjit Ghosh on July 27, 2009 at 7:28 PM
Thanks Anish for the nitpick. I agree about the corner darkening, possibly from light fall-off/lens vignetting. here is a quick and dirty rework - less corner darkening and cascade toned down a bit.
Posted by Steve Sieren on July 28, 2009 at 12:34 AM
I like it, the photo has it all, well at least 3 nice points of interest, the waterfall, flowers and colorful clouds. Not always easy place 3 elements nicely into a compostion. It does seem a little dark to me in both versions. Have you tried printing a 4x6 or a test strip maybe? Could just be time to recalibrate for me. I guess I'll be doing that a little later tonight. The dark scene could just be what you were aiming for Debjit.
An extremely wonderful scene, Debjit. Although it's hard to tell at this web size, but it looks like it could use a bit more work in the deeper shadow areas possibly, but overall a great capture to work with.
Posted by Debjit Ghosh on July 29, 2009 at 4:13 AM
Steve, I haven't yet printed it but was aiming for the darker scene to create the mood..not sure if I was successful :-)
Preston, Paul - I see enough light and details in the shadow areas. I agree that for a bright light nearby, it could be difficult.
Discussion
7 repliescomments and critiques appreciated.
thanks in advance,
debjit
I really like the composition, and the processing creates a nice mood. A couple of minor suggestions, though. The highlights in the cascade look a tad bright, especially considering the late hour. Secondly, there is some noticeable darkening on the upper right that could easily be evened out with a curves adjustment. Great job overall.
-Anish
http://farm3.static.flickr.com/2403/3763045593_aa712b4791_o.jpg
I like the composition, too. The reworked image is much better. I would like to see more detail in the dark foreground areas. The color looks nice.
-P
Preston, Paul - I see enough light and details in the shadow areas. I agree that for a bright light nearby, it could be difficult.