Nik Software Complete Collection: LR vs. PS plug-in

I'm about ready to order the Nik Complete Collection but I have one question: Is there any benefit to ordering the $399 Photoshop/LR/Aperture plug-in vs. the $249 LR/Aperture plug-in?

Obviously, you get the PS plug-in w/ the more expensive version. I understand that. I'm just wondering if there is any reason you would need to use the plug-in in PS instead of doing all your work in the LR plug-in.

Hi Bret. I've only seen it being used at the expo and have not used it myself, but this seems to confirm what I was thinking...that the it allows for selective editing rather than just changes to the entire image. Here's a link:

http://www.niksoftware.com/completecollection/usa/entry.php?view=intro/selective.shtml

Thanks, Jennifer. I'm familiar with what the software does. I'm trying to find out if the PS version offers something the LR version doesn't for the extra $150. I'm thinking the LR version is probably just fine.

I'm trying to find out if the PS version offers something the LR version doesn't for the extra $150.

NIK tech support could probably give you the definitive answer, but I suspect the PS plug-in will allow you to use all the advantages that layers offer (e.g. different blend modes, masking, etc.).

Thanks, John. I guess I'll contact NIK on Monday.

Bret,
What John says is correct.....lets you take advantage of masking, blends modes, etc. Anything that uses layers.
Joe Rogers

Lightroom version ...

1. Select your photo file (hopefully a RAW with edits in place)
2. "Edit in NIK __________".
2. A "pop-up" window for the software appears
3. Work your magic, Save
4. Takes you back to Lightroom, single-layer TIFF copy automatically rendered

Photoshop version ...

1. Open your photo file
2. Filter > Nik Software > __________
3. A "pop-up" window for the software appears
4. Work your magic, Save
5. Additional layer, with effect applied, created in your original file

No reason to buy the PS package, if you own both PS and LR ... in my opinion. One of the major benefits of the NIK software is the control point technology - which seriously reduces the need for layers. And it's nice not to leave LR if you don't need to. Grain of salt ... I'm a huge fan of LR these days, and only use PS/layers when absolutely necessary.

I would certainly demo both versions - putting each plug-in through a few tests (b/w conversion, fine tuning color, color effects, noise reduction, etc).

Someday, you know LR will have layering capability. Until then, you probably can't go wrong either way - choosing a version that reflects your workflow (LR intensive vs. PS intensive).

Brett, seems like decision depends mostly on your workflow and how/when you plan to use the various Nik apps. Wondering what Nat Coalson advises.

Bill Brennan

Thanks for the comments & suggestions, folks. Based on these and some additional research it looks like the LR package will be sufficient for my needs.

Bret,
Where did you find those prices. When I have looked on the website I always see it for more even with the NAPP discount.

Neil: B&H Photo

Bret,

If you use B&H make sure to access it through bing cashback and you'll get some money back!

RichieV

Thanks for the tip on Bing Cashback, Richie. Hadn't heard of it but now I'm in the mood to shop!

Just ordered the software from B&H. You can expect a full review on my blog after I've had time to learn and use it.

Thanks Bret. Just checked B&H and saw it for $244 (discount applied).

Look forward to reading your review.