I agree with Brett about som more space on the left, but otherwise a lovely shot.
Posted by Brett Lewis on March 15, 2010 at 12:00 PM
Interesting that my post seems to have disappeared..? Anyway, it went something along the lines of a well executed image but only nit would be a little more space on the LHS.. For w a while I couldn't get back into UKNP forums so I think there must have been an error along the lines somewhere..?
Lovely shot but it looks quite tilted. Of course I know it's a mountain environment and I'm sure you got your camera horizontal but it doesn't look quite right to me.
But it's a great shot anyway. I just bend my head 45 degrees to the right
Ed
Posted by Paul Rosser on March 15, 2010 at 2:45 PM
Great stuff!
Paul.
Posted by Karen Summers on March 15, 2010 at 2:57 PM
great shot love the splash of red
Posted by eric weight on March 15, 2010 at 3:14 PM
Excellent shot John. The male peering over the rock sets it up nicely especially with the red splash as has been mentioned. if this is a crop, I would try levelling it up to see how it looks. It may be how it was, but rightly or wrongly, it does look little unhappy at that angle. I think it is the heather apparently growing at 45 degrees that does it.
eric
Posted by Andy Elliott on March 15, 2010 at 3:42 PM
Not in any way a critique or helpful comment, but well done! I'm a big fan of black and white with a splash of red - rare to see it in NH photography.
Posted by Philip Newman on March 15, 2010 at 4:17 PM
Very interesting shot John, I've been looking at it for a while and the crop also seems not quite right to me either. I think that my eye is drawn to the way the ice melt on the rock is not vertical and so appears to suggest an unlevel viewpoint (or deliberate crop). However, as I look at the background, that looks to be a typical oof valley so I just cannot make up my mind. Level / not level .. whatever.... the subject is great.
Posted by Andy Gregory on March 15, 2010 at 4:44 PM
I really like this shot a lot. I don't think there is anything wrong with the angle at all. I am used to being in a mountain environment and see nothing out of the ordinary with this. I love the colours and the position of the birds. This sort of shot makes me want to get back in to the mountains. Great stuff.
Posted by Major Gilbert on March 15, 2010 at 4:55 PM
I can imagine the excitement having been confronted by these two.
You have done a great job considering the conditions and the picture tels the story.
Posted by John Chapman on March 16, 2010 at 5:24 AM
Hi Folks, thanks for your comments. I cropped off a little at the bottom and also from the RHS. I was a bit tight on the LHS. The picture is level but I can understand people's views on this one. To me the male bird being perpendicular helps. This was taken on the side of a mountain approx 3000ft high and the Backdrop is a valley then the side of another hill.
Discussion
25 repliesDavid
Brett
Terry
Fran
Lovely shot but it looks quite tilted. Of course I know it's a mountain environment and I'm sure you got your camera horizontal but it doesn't look quite right to me.
But it's a great shot anyway. I just bend my head 45 degrees to the right
Ed
Paul.
Bob.
You have done a great job considering the conditions and the picture tels the story.
Major.
Would have loved to have seen these John, a well executed image.
Andy...
Ian