they are pretty smooth so I am going to say no. They do add a bit of color that contrasts everything else in the scene. It looks like that lens does a nice job of smoothly blurring backgrounds, much better than my cheap sigma.
Posted by Charles Mills on April 27, 2010 at 10:23 PM
I'm envious. These are among my favorite birds and I don't have a single shot.
I don't mind the flowers. They add some nice color and don't absolutely overwhelm the waxwing. If you were gonna' reprocess this image at some point, perhaps darkening the ones closest to the bird a bit would be an arguable plus. But, I think it's pretty doggone good as is.
Posted by Aaron Szabo on April 27, 2010 at 10:36 PM
Nice shot Daniel. I think the BG is fine.
As much as I hate the push/pull design of the 100-400 Canon, it's is a wonderful lens for the price and great even on full-frames. I sold my 100-400mm and kept my Canon 300mm f/4 L IS, which is wonderful, but it's not handy like that zoom. If they made that more like the 70-200 and made it an f/4, the 100-400 would be the sweetest lens ever.
Posted by Daniel Loomis on April 27, 2010 at 10:46 PM
Aaron - my experience with the 100-400mm has been mixed. I've gotten great shots with it at times and at others been totally disappointed. It works best within the 20-50ft range. Beyond that it cannot resolve images with the clarity I expect from an L lens. The 500 f/4 on the other hand is a true gem. I will be getting it back later this week. It has been on loan since January.
Posted by Daniel Loomis on April 27, 2010 at 10:51 PM
Another view of the same Cedar Waxwing
Posted by Karla Hall on April 27, 2010 at 11:05 PM
Great shots Daniel! I love all the color in the background. It really helps to set of the Waxwing...
Posted by Larry Fischer on April 28, 2010 at 8:48 AM
I like the second shot best.
Very nice work, as usual.
the fisch
I like both shots, I really like the pinks in the background. They are composed very nicely with the bird.
Posted by John Moore on April 28, 2010 at 10:59 AM
Both are wonderful shots. On the first one, I find the pink in the lower right a bit distracting, but the background is a big plus. On the second one, the leaves in the foreground are a bit distracting... maybe they could be darkened up a little? But those are nitpicks... you should be proud of both of these images.
Posted by Brad Mangas on April 28, 2010 at 11:56 AM
Wonderful shots Daniel, if anything maybe just a little darkening of the brighter backgrounds. If you use photoshop you can select just those tones and tweak the brightness down just a bit would probably work great. But overall great job! These birds are so beautiful.
Discussion
14 replies7D
100-400@400mm
f/6.3
1/80s
ISO 400
Just curious: Do you think the flowers in the BG are too distracting?
I don't mind the flowers. They add some nice color and don't absolutely overwhelm the waxwing. If you were gonna' reprocess this image at some point, perhaps darkening the ones closest to the bird a bit would be an arguable plus. But, I think it's pretty doggone good as is.
As much as I hate the push/pull design of the 100-400 Canon, it's is a wonderful lens for the price and great even on full-frames. I sold my 100-400mm and kept my Canon 300mm f/4 L IS, which is wonderful, but it's not handy like that zoom. If they made that more like the 70-200 and made it an f/4, the 100-400 would be the sweetest lens ever.
Very nice work, as usual.
the fisch