A few times I've had an image that I had specific questions about and also that I thought had a major flaw or flaws, so I've posted them here instead of in the galleries.
Also, per your feedback, I think that my work is improving, and I don't want to disappoint those of you who have put so much effort into helping me.
Also, I don't want you to think I'm necessarily going backward if I am experimenting in a new area.
So, is it best for me to continue posting experimental pictures in the forums rather than in the galleries, or does it not matter? Thank you.
All but a few of us have ups and downs, Barbara, so no worries about "going backward." I don't know if there's a specific policy or not re: "experimental pictures." Seems like most of mine are experimental. But seriously, that's why taking lots of shots with different apertures, shutter speeds, perspective, light, etc., are so important. I know I've posted lots of "just for fun" or "thought I'd try this" images in the critique galleries and received lots of helpful feedback. Anyway, if there's a problem, one of the moderators will let you know in a characteristically NPN polite way. So, I vote for shooting, posting, and having fun!
I usually think in terms of "most bang for my buck," Barbara.
In the context of your question, that would mean getting the most responses when posted in a gallery where people with the most interest in that style of photography hang out. If you're not getting what you need there, I'd go to the discussion forums with the question- e.g., Digital Imaging if it's a processing question, etc. I base that on my impression that you get quicker and sometimes more responses in the galleries. On the other hand, you might get a broader range of views in the discussion forums, even if it took a little longer to get them.
Posted by Bill Fach on October 10, 2010 at 3:02 PM
Barbara: I would encourage you to post in the galleries. Speaking for Flora I think you will get more specific feedback from those who work in the same genre, particularly if you pose a specific question regarding comp, lighting, DOF, etc. Also feel free to post compare and contrast images in the same thread. A fair number of folks do that when posting a color and B&W conversion of the same shot. Your openness also makes it easier for folks to be free with their advice. Bring 'em on. >=))>
Posted by Lon Overacker on October 10, 2010 at 6:01 PM
Barbara,
The galleries are pretty much for image critique. So, if you have questions or want feedback with regards to composition, sharpness, color, DOF, processing - relating to your image, then the galleries are appropriate.
If, however, you have a general question on technique, like a "How to use the hyper focal distance for focusing?" or "how do I calibrate my monitor?" etc., then I would post those questions in the various forums for discussion.
Hope that helps,
Lon
Posted by Nathan Buck on October 11, 2010 at 1:33 PM
I would post experimental shots in the galleries for sure Barbara. You are not going to be the only one who benefits from the comments and critiques that happen on images, whether they are experimental or polished. Post them all!
Discussion
5 repliesAlso, per your feedback, I think that my work is improving, and I don't want to disappoint those of you who have put so much effort into helping me.
Also, I don't want you to think I'm necessarily going backward if I am experimenting in a new area.
So, is it best for me to continue posting experimental pictures in the forums rather than in the galleries, or does it not matter? Thank you.
In the context of your question, that would mean getting the most responses when posted in a gallery where people with the most interest in that style of photography hang out. If you're not getting what you need there, I'd go to the discussion forums with the question- e.g., Digital Imaging if it's a processing question, etc. I base that on my impression that you get quicker and sometimes more responses in the galleries. On the other hand, you might get a broader range of views in the discussion forums, even if it took a little longer to get them.
The galleries are pretty much for image critique. So, if you have questions or want feedback with regards to composition, sharpness, color, DOF, processing - relating to your image, then the galleries are appropriate.
If, however, you have a general question on technique, like a "How to use the hyper focal distance for focusing?" or "how do I calibrate my monitor?" etc., then I would post those questions in the various forums for discussion.
Hope that helps,
Lon
Nathan