Hi all,
Ive seen great macro images with amazing dof and found out they were done using the focus stacking method or blending of layers. I finally gave it a shot yet found my final image had a faint line where one of the layer masks was. How do I not get these lines? I learned the technique on line at: http://youtu.be/ZiwHsbrMycA
Thanks
I have used (use) Helicon Focus, but the best stacking program--or the one I've had most success with, maybe, is Photoshop CS5. I "export to PS as layers" from Lightroom. Then have PS align the layers, and then blend the layers. I think it does the best job of aligning. However, if there are "ghosts" with Helicon Focus, you can brush in/out parts of other layers, or clone, or whatever needs to be done. For more perfect alignment, use Helicon Remote with camera on a tripod - or just shoot a series under your own steam with regular adjustments of the focus. I haven't had much experience (or success) with manual blending - seems like you might need to feather the mask? I'm sure someone more skilled than I will have input - this is just my limited experience.
My experience with stacking in CS5 has not been positive. This image was my first and only attempt at focus stacking in CS5. I followed the technique demonstrated in the Photoshop.com tutorials. The ghosting at the edges of the petals and the around the stamens really put me off. This is a stack of 10 images and I did align them first. I have not tried Helicon or Zerene yet.
I think that kind of problem with CS5 stacking, Steve, is because it only does a basic align. And as the focus point changes with a macro lens, the magnification changes too, so you can't just pick a few points and align them - one image will actually have a larger flower, in this case. Supposedly - as I said I've never used them - Helicon Focus and Zerene Stacker take care of this kind of thing easily.
Cheryl, I've tried both (CS5 and Helicon) and find Helicon much better. In my view, it does a better job of aligning and it is much less memory hungary. I can stack >20 images, using minute focusing adjustments easily with Helicon...even with Lightroom open as well, but if I try to stack more than about 10 images in CS5 I run out of memory...and I ihave 8 GB of RAM and am running the 64 bit version. btw, by using more images I can shoot with my sweetspot aperature rather than stopped down. Another thing I love about Helicon is that I can selectively add or drop individual images from the stack, thus creating my own selective focus planes...muc like a lensbaby...if I want. This gives me a huge amount of creative control. Here is a recent image of an Easter Lily, which has a huge amount of depth. About 15 image stack, but with a few selectively dropped. I'd show you the CS5 version but I didn't have enough memory to run it and running it with just 5 or 6 stach looked awful,
Discussion
8 repliesIve seen great macro images with amazing dof and found out they were done using the focus stacking method or blending of layers. I finally gave it a shot yet found my final image had a faint line where one of the layer masks was. How do I not get these lines? I learned the technique on line at: http://youtu.be/ZiwHsbrMycA
Thanks