ID please

I think this is a pine siskin, not positive. There were a few of these with the streaked undersides hanging out with some goldfinches. Been wanting to see/photograph pine siskins for some time. It looks like the photo of one at the nature center. The bird in the larger image flew over the nature center as I was photographing the siskins. Not sure what it is. It was a snap shot. My first thought is a osprey. But can't say for sure.

Thanks for your help.

Yes to Pine Siskin. The hawk is a Red-tailed Hawk, notice especially the dark patagial mark (on the leading edge of the wing).

Thanks Brian, appreicate your ID ing these birds. I should have known about the redtail, just seemed different from the ones I usually see around here.

Redtails are extremely variable in their plumage, John--they can be tricky, especially in tough light like here. another good mark that is visible is the dark belly band.

Concur on everything Brian has to say. This year (at least in NY) has been phenomenal for the number of siskins moving through on migration

Thanks everyone. Now that I can ID pine siskins they seem to be in large numbers at the nature center, at least for now.