Kapuskasing River

I like the composition here, Michel. The eye follows the left hand border of the image and is pulled to the right by the continuous cover of red clouds. An unusual composition, but I feel it works nicely. The saturation seems quite strong on my monitor. Nice work!

Holy cow, that was some sunset! I think the sat looks about right, obviously the colors were strong here so i think they should be presented as such. The reds look in bounds. Id try to shift the cyan in the sky more towards blue though. I like the dark presnetation overall, but the vignette on the lhs is a bit much, epsecially up top where the sky goes nearly black. A few tweaks and this will be kliller!

The light here is awesome! I like the way some of the leaves are glowing echoing that incredible sky! I usually don't like lots of saturation but in this case it really works for me...

I think the reds seem super saturated, but on the other hand, I don't find them objectionable at all. I think it suits the image, and I think you've done a fine job of crafting it. I particularly like your foreground - the apparent reds in the foliage with the white edges (frost?) is nice eye candy. It appears that you added a darkening vignette to the left side. I'm a big fan of edge darkening, but I might point out that it IS noticeable in the sky. Whether that's good or bad is subjective. I wouldn't want it any darker in this instance, but IMO it's fine the way it is.

Comp and mood are nice, reds do seem a bit pumped but might seem more in line if the cyan/blue was adjusted as Stan suggests.

Yeah, what Stan said. I would just try to eliminate the blacks in the sky.

WOW!! Eye-popping image. I happen to like it as is. Love how the foreground vegetation echoes the color of the sky. And again... WOW!!

I love the composition, I especially like how the foliage in the foreground has a glow to it. This is a shot to be proud of.

This is a great image Michael but IMO it looks a bit dark and a little over saturated. I say this because both cyan and the reds are strong. I would recommend adjusting the density first then the saturation.

Nice composition, especially the foreground leaves. Looks like a pretty epic sunset. That being said, the saturation does look a little strong to me and maybe a little dark overall. A little more tweaking could make an already nice image really sing.

Whoa, that is some amazing color. Gorgeous.

Many thanks everyone for your comments and suggestions. This is very helpful and exacly what I was looking for! Michel

I like the red foliage and the composition in general, not sure about the sky saturation, feels a bit heavy. Stan had a good suggestion.

Michel, I like it as posted. Not sure if you will lose some focus on the nice front leaves if you lighten anything else. The mood would change for sure...If it were mine... I'd wipe my hands together and click print.

Very nice image Michel. The saturation is definitely high, but I don't feel it's over the top. I really like how you have reds in both the foreground and sky. If you can pull some of that cyan out the sky, I think you will have a winner.

I like the image as posted. It is obvious that the image is saturated beyond reality but if it provides an attractive image like this one, well then that's fine, I would think? If you want the viewer to think this is a natural scene then I would reduce the saturation a little
Grt, Ingrid.